An airy cream sitting room with a limestone fireplace and linen armchair beside a window overlooking a lightly snow-dusted winter garden.

What Scarsdale's Winter Home Sales Actually Look Like

In the last week of February, with nearly 20 inches of snow on the way, two Scarsdale houses closed. Scarsdale10583 reported the sales on February 26: 13 Hillview Drive at $2,051,000 and 105 Sprague Road at $1,215,000. A week earlier, the same outlet reported a single closing, new construction at 6 Cooper Road, at $7,995,000.

Those weeks were quiet, and the prices were not soft. That pattern matters to anyone deciding whether to shop or list in Scarsdale between now and spring. In this village the winter slowdown comes from a shortage of listings. Buyers stay. Because so few homes trade in any one month, the off-season averages tell you less than the individual deals do.

Listings Are What Drops Off in Winter

A January 1 forecast published by Scarsdale10583 put the starting point plainly. Scarsdale entered 2026 with 13 single-family homes on the market, compared with 29 at the start of 2024 and a pre-COVID average of 89. The same forecast said the 2025 median sale price rose 9% to $2.465 million, and homes priced at $3 million and up made up 32% of 2025 sales, compared with 21% in 2024.

This fall looks much the same. The William Pitt Sotheby's Market Tracker for the Scarsdale School District counted 10 new single-family listings in October 2026. That was 23.1% fewer than in October 2025 and 37.5% fewer than in October 2024. One brokerage count put Scarsdale's single-family inventory at 14 homes at the end of October 2026, or about 1.8 months of supply. So Scarsdale is heading into this winter with about the same number of homes for sale as it had entering last winter.

Demand did not fade over the same stretch. On October 14, Scarsdale10583 described the slower autumn pace and said the small number of sales "may reflect a shortage of available homes rather than a lack of buyer interest."

Eight Sales Can Swing an Average

With supply this thin, every monthly figure for Scarsdale rests on a handful of houses. The Market Tracker recorded eight single-family sales in the district in October 2026. Those eight sold at an average of 112% of asking, with a $2.5 million median and an average of 20 days on market. The days-on-market figure was down 84.6% from October 2025, which means the October 2025 average was roughly 130 days. With fewer than a dozen sales in each of those months, a swing that large tells you more about which houses closed than about how the market moved.

The year as a whole is steadier. The tracker counts 157 single-family sales in the district from January through October 2026, about 16 a month and 6.0% fewer than in the same months of 2025. In winter the monthly count falls well below that average, and a single estate sale can move the median by hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Edgemont, which shares Scarsdale's postal address, showed how far one sale can move a number. Scarsdale10583's first-quarter report listed 10 Edgemont sales in Q1 2026 at a $1,925,000 median, up 75% from $1,100,000 in Q1 2025, and the report itself cautioned that a single large sale could skew a sample that small. Edgemont houses did not gain 75% in value in a year. The mix of houses that happened to close changed.

What Closed Last December Through February

Scarsdale10583's weekly roundups give the clearest picture of a Scarsdale winter, because they name the houses. These are the single-family closings the outlet reported from mid-December 2025 through February 2026, drawn from its December 17, January 1, January 7, February 5, February 19 and February 26 roundups:

Report date Address Sale price As described
Dec. 17, 2025 100 Garden Road $2,850,000 Updated Colonial
Jan. 1, 2026 16 High Point Lane $2,050,000 Estate-style home on more than an acre
Jan. 7, 2026 233 Nelson Road $2,499,000 Move-in-ready new construction, Edgewood
Feb. 5, 2026 1 Duck Pond Road $9,950,000 Renovated 2014 estate, Heathcote
Feb. 5, 2026 9 Broadmoor Road $3,000,000 Four-bedroom Colonial
Feb. 19, 2026 6 Cooper Road $7,995,000 New construction
Feb. 26, 2026 13 Hillview Drive $2,051,000
Feb. 26, 2026 105 Sprague Road $1,215,000

Two of those closings were new construction, and two were large estates. The February 5 roundup reported an average of about $6.475 million for that week's two sales and described the market as competitive, especially for larger or recently renovated homes. In January, the week's roundup reported a single closing and described the market as still emerging from the holiday slowdown, with low inventory and strong buyer demand.

Winter sales were few, and many of them were expensive. Nothing in this list points to discounted winter houses.

Scarsdale Did Not Follow the County's Winter Pattern

Across Westchester County, winter does change the terms. OneKey MLS figures for county single-family homes show an average of 51 days on market in Q1 2026, compared with 34 in Q2 and 28 in Q3. Sellers received 100.6% of original list price in Q1 2026, compared with 106.9% in Q2 and 106.2% in Q3. The county median also dropped in winter, to $935,000 in Q1 2026 from $1,211,228 in Q2, about 23% lower. County listings followed the same seasonal swing, with 823 new single-family listings in Q4 2025, 1,263 in Q1 2026 and 2,227 in Q2 2026.

Scarsdale's winter median held up. The first-quarter report counted 25 Scarsdale sales in Q1 2026, the same number as in Q1 2025, at a $2,408,000 median. That was 4% above the $2,320,000 median in Q1 2025. It was also within about 2% of the village's $2.465 million full-year 2025 median. When a market holds only a dozen or so homes for sale, the few that list in January still have buyers waiting for them. In a deeper county market, a buyer can afford to wait for a price cut.

This Fall's Closings Point to the Same Winter

The sales Scarsdale10583 reported this autumn look a lot like last winter's. In its Q3 coverage on October 8, the outlet cited a regional report showing Lower Westchester, which includes Scarsdale and Edgemont, with 10% fewer sales and a 19% higher median sale price than in Q3 2025. That week's sales included 16 Meadow Road, which backs onto the fifth hole of Quaker Ridge Golf Club, at $3,000,000, and 6 Oakstwain Road at $1,999,995.

In mid-October, 12 Drake Road sold for $2,570,000 and 55 Argyle Road in Edgemont sold for $1,329,000. Scarsdale10583 reported that both sold above asking after fewer than 10 days on the market. The outlet's real estate page then listed 1 Rock Hill Lane at $2,400,000, 9 Parkfield Road at $2,399,000 and 27 Clarendon Road at $1,260,000 on October 29, and 113 Brambach Road at $1,430,000 on November 4. On November 12 it reported three closings in Scarsdale and Edgemont, all above asking, including 79 Penn Road at $3,650,000 and 1 Sheridan Road at $1,600,000.

Some weeks brought one sale and some brought three, and several of the sales were above asking. Sales were coming in above asking even as the number of new listings fell.

Planning a Winter Move

For a buyer, the low point of the season usually means less to choose from, with prices about where they were in the fall. The January forecast published by Scarsdale10583 said homes listed below $2.5 million had been in high demand and expected that segment to stay favorable to sellers in 2026. A family shopping in that range this winter should plan to see a house early and come in with financing ready, the same as in spring. Be careful with a monthly median that seems to show prices sliding or jumping, because it may reflect three sales instead of thirty. The market reports page and the individual sales behind it are better guides than one month's headline figure.

For a seller, the same thin supply cuts the other way. A Scarsdale house listed in January competes with roughly a dozen others, not the much larger spring crop. The same forecast also noted that some higher-end sellers have been testing private listings first to signal price before going fully public. Winter presentation takes more work: photos taken in short daylight, walkways cleared, rooms warm and bright for showings. Our guides to staging Scarsdale homes and the Scarsdale listing timeline cover the preparation. To see where your own house might fall in this winter's small pool, a home valuation is a good place to start.

Common Questions

Do Scarsdale prices drop in winter? Last winter's numbers say no. Scarsdale's Q1 2026 median of $2,408,000 was 4% above Q1 2025's and close to the 2025 full-year median, even though Westchester County's Q1 median dropped well below its spring level.

Why do Scarsdale's monthly figures jump around so much? Each month rests on a small number of sales. Eight single-family homes sold in the district in October 2026, so one estate or one slow sale can move the average days on market or the median a long way.

How many Scarsdale homes are typically for sale in winter? Very few. Scarsdale entered 2026 with 13 single-family homes on the market, and one count put this fall's figure at 14 at the end of October.

If you're weighing a winter listing against a spring one, or deciding whether to keep searching through the cold months, a conversation with Jennifer Baldinger about the recent Scarsdale sales closest to your house and price range is a sensible first step. Schedule a consultation.

WORK WITH JENNIFER

Real estate is more than transactions — it’s trust, strategy, and vision. I combine local expertise, marketing savvy, and a sharp eye for design to help clients buy smarter and sell with confidence. From first-time buyers to luxury sellers, I guide every step.

Follow Me on Instagram